Yes Herb and Judith should have moved in with Allen into the beach house that would have brought in some different relationships between them and it would have been much funnier to watch or you could have tried the idea that someone else suggested too, Charlie was in the hospital for months and he eventually came back to the beach house. He had a coma but he wakes up in about 2 months because his family is there to sit with him. Alan would say some funny comments and that would work to wake up Charlie. It could have worked Allan and Charlie had a great relationship together!! I wanted to say that I don't like the new cast member who is on the show because she is acting just like Charlie would have. A female drunk, who stays in the beach house alot isn't a very actress.