Kate is living the dream in New York, modeling and dating, but she's still trying to find herself and often longs for her Amish roots. She misses the simpler life, which she experiences while hanging out with Katie-Ann and Mary, Abe's sister and mother, in Punxsutawney. When they come knocking on her door in New York, worlds collide with Fashion Week in full swing and Kate anxiously preparing for the opportunity of a lifetime.